Eddie G's Steak Place

  1. Oh dear. Avoid at all costs.
  2. Below expectations.
  3. OK. Met expectations.
  4. I really enjoyed this.
  5. Amazing. Would unreservedly recommend.
  6. rating

1060 Route 25aDavis Ave & Route 25A, Mt Sinai, 11766

I went on a Saturday night. They don't accept reservations but do allow a call ahead. Upon arrival the place was dark and cramped...We couldn't sit down without asking the next table to let us into our seats. You are on top of the tables next to you. It took a long while before anyone came to take a drink order. They told us that 2 of the 4 tap beers were out of stock and not expected in till next week. The bus boy pouring water actually had the pitcher touch the cups people drank...

Reviews for Eddie G's Steak Place

I went on a Saturday night. They don't accept reservations but do allow a call ahead. Upon arrival the place was dark and cramped...We couldn't sit down without asking the next table to let us into our seats. You are on top of the tables next to you. It took a long while before anyone came to take a drink order. They told us that 2 of the 4 tap beers were out of stock and not expected in till next week. The bus boy pouring water actually had the pitcher touch the cups people drank from and continued on to the next table. We got a menu and almost fell out of our chairs. Steaks were between $30 and 36 and other entrees averaged $25-28. They did have a burger on the menu for $10.
We ordered a NY Strip steak at $30.00, which came with a salad (dressing was awful) sweet mashed potatoes and a very heavy seasoned mixed veggies that were soggy. Baked potatoes were $6 extra and a horseradish source set you back another $1. They brough out a basket of bread that was stale and cold. The meal arrived and the steak was full of grizle. No one in the resturant seamed to care about the guests and I heard a couple of people complaining about the service and quality of food. You could not help hearing you were basically on top of them. I give this establishment ZERO stars and unless you want to waste your money stay away from it.

Top places nearby
  • American Restaurants
    Immaculately clean diner, they must be running their employees endlessly...
  • Night Clubs
    To sum it up in 2 words: overpriced headache. I've been to this place...
Restaurants nearby

USA > New York > Mt Sinai > Restaurants > Eddie G's Steak Place